Fast Company has a very cute article, “Brutally honest versions of your job titles.” I smiled through “Brand Ambassador = Professional Conference Attendee,” and “Social Media Strategist = Person with the Twitter password.” I suppose that since I do not work in one of those professions, I could chuckle a bit, understanding the subtle poke at their work.
Then I came to “HR Director = Gossip Coordinator/Instigator.” Aw no – that’s hitting below the belt. That is the antithesis of everything that anyone in Human Resources hopes to be. Our world revolves around confidentiality, and here is a popular business magazine calling us gossips and instigators. There are a lot of “names” I can rationalize because I know we sometimes fall into the trap – Party planner, Evil HR lady, and “oh oh, here comes HR – someone’s gonna be fired.” But not “gossip.”
This bothers me. Granted we struggle with being strategic, with being real business partners but I believe, with a few shifts in our work, we can achieve that partnership. If we are seen as gossips however, we are doomed.
I’ll go out on a limb here and suggest that the author of this article must have had one particularly bad experience with confidentiality and HR, thus decided to be “brutally honest” and label HR as a gossip. Surely, this is an isolated instance and limited to this author. Surely, this is not a pervasive perception of our profession.
We have to do something about this, folks. We need to work together to change the image of HR, or we are forever doomed to a Dilbertian existence. How can we do that? Perhaps there are some immediate actions we can take….
Acknowledge the special circumstances surrounding the role of HR in an organization.
We know more about the people in an organization than any other group. We know their salaries, their family members, their family status, their performance, their work problems, their work history – everything. This is a serious obligation for us and places us in a realm that is different than any ordinary employee. We are trusted with this information, and therefore should be completely above reproach. Whether or not we divulge information isn’t relevant; if it is perceived that we divulge information, we have violated that trust.
As HR professionals, we can’t be part of the crowd. We have to hold ourselves to a higher standard.
Be the keeper of the values of the organization.
Not only must we hold ourselves to a higher standard, but we have the opportunity to raise the standard for the organization by influencing leadership to see the value in their people. We must walk a fine line between being an advocate for the people, and being an advocate for the business and this is a tightrope that is difficult to maneuver. The bottom line is, everyone in an organization is there to support and drive the organization forward, otherwise, there is no job.
We have to help the organization discover what is important, and stand by those values.
We may not be liked
Being an effective HR professional may not get us liked, but if our decisions are made to make people like us personally, they will likely be the wrong decisions. We need to put aside personal needs, and make business decisions that are right for the organization and for the employees. Too many of us came to this profession because we are “people people.” HR is about the business first. The work of the people part of HR IS business work.
I don’t like seeing my profession represented this way, and I suspect I am not alone. This is a call to action. Let’s change our reputation, shall we?
2 thoughts on “Let’s be brutally honest…”
Thank you, Carol, 1. I prefer to say, “Respectfully honest” and yes, this was Brutal. I attend a group and we give 30 second elevator pitches, one woman in HR, always starts with, “I put the HUMAN in Human Resources.” Perhaps we can couch it that way.
Hi Deb…I agree that respectfully is a much better way to go about honesty, but this writer truly was brutal, and I couldn’t pass up the opportunity to say my peace. This profession of which I am part has some failings, but this isn’t one of them. I also feel strongly that HR isn’t just the people, it’s the business of helping the people be productive and grow, with a view toward helping and growing the business. Otherwise, there won’t be a business.
Thanks for your comment.